Erin Caffey was well-known throughout her small Texas town of Emory as a preacher’s pretty daughter whom everyone wanted to be around. Her life started resembling that of Nicole Walker, a character played by Reese Witherspoon in James Foley’s 1996 film, Fear. Like Nicole, when Erin began dating the town bad boy, Charlie Wilkinson, her parents disapproved and forbade her from seeing him again. However, this only upset the young couple and sent them on a bloody rampage, much like the horrors that take place in Fear.